Definitely! This scene is so much more powerful and grand. Evil Queen's transformation is nice too, though.

Mostly because of the FAR superior animations

I am blown away by both! I love them even though both are long and dramatic.
The Evil Queen's gives me the chills with every thing she adds to the potions. Just seeing her drop the glass, the spinning feeling, the bubbles, the colors, and her aging takes my breath away. That animation!
Kenai's is so beautiful, with an emotional edge to it. I enjoy every second of it. I love how it starts slow and blue and mysterious, then bursts into the Northern Lights with all of the animals. That music is heavenly! When I hear it I feel like I'm floating on a cloud, but sad at the same time.

This was beautiful. Not just the animation but the music is amazing.

I'm hoping we'll be able to get a northern lights scene in Frozen, that would be soooo beautiful!!!!!

Ooooh! YES! You should work for Disney and give them some amazing ideas.

The animation is amazing!

Both are amazing though.

This is a breathtaking scene; the animation and music is just stunning.

Great music and animation.

And Nina's in the second movie. I personally liked the 2nd movie better, but that's my opininion.