answer this question

Emmett & Rosalie Question

How do you see Rosalie in 'Breaking Dawn'?

Everyone always talks about how selfish and mean she is in BD (and all of the series), but what do you think of her???

My Comment: I think of Rosalie as the victim almost. I mean she was finally excepting her life as a vampire after over 100 years but then her brother betrays the family by bringing a human into her home which puts her family she has come to know and her true love in danger again and again. Then to make things worse Edward falls in love with Bella and gets her pregnant. Rosalie pretty much has to sit back and watch this girl live her dream literally right in front of her face. How would you feel? Only Emmett understands her and you don't get to see that in the books (or movies) very well. I hate when people say that Rosalie doesn't deserve Emmett but that is completely not true. They are each others reason for living. All Rosalie was doing was making sure Bella knew the consequences of her decision.

And when people say that Rosalie would give up Emmett, in my opinion, is not true. Yes it is written in the books that she would but I believe that if Rosalie had the chance to become human again, she would at first choice, and Emmett would want her to so she could go live her dream. But after a few days I think Rosalie would become lost and wouldn't know what to do. She couldn't live with out her Emmett, her soul mate. Hence the words 'soul mate'.

That is all my opinion though.

 MajorFan2500 posted over a year ago
next question »

Emmett & Rosalie Answers

RosalieLHale said:
I think we really have a problem here. If you don't stop reading my thoughts, I'm going to go mad. :P
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Haha, sorry. :)
MajorFan2500 posted over a year ago
TwilightLovarr said:
Wow, that's EXACTLY the way how I think about it.

And Bella wants to throw everything away she wants (humanity and children) right in front of her. I get the feeling that Edward just doesn't understand her. I mean, I've read a part of Midnight Sun on Stephenie's site, and it's just awful how Edward thinks of Rosalie. And just because Edward thinks that, everybody thinks it's true. But we shouldn't forget, is that's HIS opinion about her. And he's just pissed because Rosalie isn't like Alice "best friends" with Bella. Rosalie has all the rights to be mad and only Emmett can tell us how his Angel really is. Not Edward nor Bella.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I Don't Think It's Like That! It's Not What Edward Feels Or Whatever! It's More Of How Stephenie Meyer Portrayed Her Character! I Agree With Everything That MajorFan2500 Has To Say! But I Don't Really Think It's Because Of Edward That Some Fans Feel That Way! I Think It's Because Stephenie Meyer Wanted To Have A Conflict Within The Family! And Of Course Rosalie Is The Perfect One For That! She's Ever More Beautiful Than The Rest Of The Cullens, So Naturally She Makes Her Seem Selfish! It's Just because She's Prettiest! That's Why She's The One Stephenie Meyer Wanted To Pick On!
shivers-zimmy posted over a year ago
*
I agree with both of you. Since about 90% (my estimate) of the Twilight fanbase is Edward, Jacob, and Bella fans and not one of those characters are really a big fan of Rosalie, naturally she isn't one of the most liked characters. And only convinently only getting to hear Bella, Edward, and Jacob's POV during the series deffinitly doesn't help anything. But I also think that if Stephanie Meyer were to write a book souly about Emmett and Roaslie that she wouldn't sound like such a b!t*h. Even though Rosalie fans know she's not one.
MajorFan2500 posted over a year ago
*
I agree with MajorFan2500. It's only Bella, Jacob and Edward POV. You can't know exactly how Rosalie is. The same for Esme, Carlisle and all the other Cullens. That's why I think that. It's known that Rosalie and Edward aren't best friends. But they love each other. Rosalie seems like a bitch but she isn't. If you read Emmett and the bear on Stephenie's website, you see how Emmett thinks of Rosalie. And how can such a person be a bitch? Tell me, how? She truly cares about her family and she loves Emmett dearly. I hate it when people say she's a bitch.
TwilightLovarr posted over a year ago
*
wow...majorfan2500 that took some work to rite that lol yeah ur really rite i would luv if she rote another book just in the lives of each of the cullen with thier mates and then in the time when rosealie and emmeett went to go find people tin their resistance against the volturi lol yeah she seems like a caring person but he experience in becoming a vampire by force was just so heatbreaking i think she feels anger from that.
vampacademy posted over a year ago
Rosemmett said:
wow i completely agree with your comment!it's exactly what i think too :D
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Emmalie1935 said:
MajorFan2500 you totally took the words out of my mouth =D
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
sapherequeen said:
You took the words right out of my mouth....well, more like typed the words. :)

Team Rosalie For Life!! =D
select as best answer
You took the words right out of my mouth....well, more like typed the words. :)

Team Rosalie For Life!! =D
posted over a year ago 
*
luv the pic
vampacademy posted over a year ago
*
I love it too, Rosalie is gorgeous :)
sapherequeen posted over a year ago
vampacademy said:
i think ur rite...she really has always just wanted a child and she is just thinking of bellas kid as hers and she just...she just wants to take that kid outta bella and run away her ad emmmett i feel badfor her :(
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
hjf1212 said:
I think rosalie is just mad at carsile for not giving her a choice at being a vampire or not being a vampire
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »