Do you think archie comics is bullshit?

Well I think yes... (why?) :'D
Be cause characters lives are changed are changed, because many characters like Sally, Julie-Su, Anthonie, Bunny, Lupe are actually not SEGA (Be careful I said SEGA) characters just Archie shit~

Plus I hate all those fights in which people are fighting who will be with Sonic (Amy or Sally etc.) or any other character~

Guys I don't see problem -3- Just support couple you like and IGNORE those random trolls~ I mean just fandom -w-''

Anyway kids in future are actually Archie kids not SEGA TwT SEGA sould made the real Sonic's story about life in future :'3
Plus I think Amy is better for Sonic (Now don't attack me trolls/fans because of this anyway I have rights to say) :D because she is SEGA character and I really like couple~<3 (Amy is maded even earlier then all Archie characters)~☺

The End
Now kids go home xD I'm gonna play Dofus~

Definitely not, The Archie comic series is fully endorsed and supported by Sega so to say many of the characters are not "Sega" defies logic.

Furthermore, What has the game side of sonic given us in the past few years as far as new characters? Chip? Genies and King Arthur? No the Comic Franchise does complete adaptations of all of the game from the Death Egg saga to the lesser know Sonic labyrinth games,

They did a great job and did not create a whole new universe, yet they expanded on the one that was already there.

Sega Gave the rights to Archie to create Sonic's epic history going forward, and that makes it about as official as you can get,

There is a reason it stands as the most successful game Adaptation comic of all time,

Thank you, granted this is opinion but I believe I added a fair amount of fact as well

hell no! they're awsome

One word: No

Reason?: Because every Sonic franchises from comics, games and TV shows should be loved equally and fairly from any "fans" of Sonic, if you haven't seen most of the comics then you have no reason to rant about it.

the end.

I find them to be quite a nice read, only around issue 60 since my computer keeps crashing when I try to open the file they're in (

Well, I don't like archie comics but I like some characters..

I'm not much of a comics fan, but I find some of the characters interesting and may read some of the comics on Youtube if I like the plot summary.

But I prefer the comics original characters over the game characters they use. I dunno there's something about how the portray the game characters sometimes that rubs me the wrong way but I'm not TOO bothered. But you can either assume it's bad characterisation on Archie's part, or due to the comics being a different continuity from the games means they decided to take artistic liberties with the game characters (one big example is that they give Mighty super strength even though in Knuckles Chaotix he didn't have any super strength)

Yes.


Archie makes Sonic really way out of character.I hate the fact that they made the old characters meet the current characters....now the couples are gonna be mixed up and crap.
They made Shadow marry Sally.
They made Fiona and Rouge whores.
They made Sonic not so interested in Amy and the same thing with Knux and Rouge...
They made Mina marry Tails... seems like a random crack couple...
The series is a meandering, overpopulated mess full of elements that don't work well together. I don't like how loopy some of the characters get with either changing personalities or violent mood swings. I also don't like the whole "alternate universe" idea, its nice for the world with the evil sally and tails and with scourge, but otherwise its a watered down idea for all other alternate universes. That being said, I do enjoy the art and the comics have a nostalgic feel about them.

No

1st off, it's Sonic, you can never have too much of him.

2nd, the charaters. All of our favorite charaters are potraied fatefully, no matter how many SEGA make. the original charaters are just as lovealbe. and they breath new life into the charaters SEGA forgot.

But mostly, the story. Even after 200 issues, the story is as compleing as ever. I'd even go so far as to say that Archie should write for SEGA games. I mean, Sonic Colors was great, but the story was crap.

no, you would understant the comics more if you read more of them


the comics are awesome!

Most definetly. Rubbish plots(Tails eats apple and becomes 10?), Rubbish OC(Scourge, the green sonic), Bad personalities for Sega characters(Rouge the biggest b*tch in the world) and nothing more than a really bad soap opera comic(Sally and Sonic's break-up, WTH!?)

I dont like the comics they just ruin the whole story... Sorry i mean THE REAL story of the franchise. Its not by SEGA, there is like 190 different characters, and the artwork makes the real SEGA characters look like they were drawn by 5 year olds just like the other non-SEGA characters.

It's way more interesting than the games logic and the characters have great personalities, so NO ;P

You know why because i am a sonamy fan i hate some of the made up character yes i hate you most of all sally and they changed some of their OFFICIAL!!!! PERSONALITIES!!!!!!!!!! So troll me off the internet i will exept thank YOU for your Time and if archie is wacthing this please make a comic with official things in it. Including sonamy:P

@LostOblivion Not exactly Amy Rose came first then Sally. The girl on your left is the prototype/first incarnation of Amy Rose. She was just called Amy in a manga published in Shogakukan's Shogakukan no Gakushuuzasshi and was written by Kenji Terada and illustrated by Sango Norimoto in 1992. She was the girlfriend of a boy named Nicky Parlouzer who can turn into Sonic the Hedgehog. And if you say that Sally was in Sonic 01 then your incorrect. Sally was just inspire by the Ricky creatures in Sonic 1. Go here for prove link)

No, I don't think it's bullshit at all. Sega DID give them pretty much free reign with this one, it's completely separate from the games, and that whole character change crap is mostly due to Ken Penders, one of the series' former writers. And hey, at 21 years and 256 issues, still going, Archie is doing SOMETHING right!

I wouldn't use the word "Bullshit". I mean, they're nice to read and all, but there are many places in the Archie Comics where I'm thinking "What the hell is this?". One thing is that they've made so many characters too OOC. However, there are a few places where the characters are IC.
I don't like how much big deal they've become either. They've caused fights and debates for nothing.
The Archie Comics are like fanfictions, where the author has created his/her own OCs (Like Julie-Su) and then written his/her own story. My Sonic fanfictions are as much real as the Archie Comics - Fake. Sega are only the sponsors of the Archie Comics. It's not theirs. Therefore, it's not "real".
But like I said, I don't mind reading them and they're not bad.
So I have to answer both yes and no on this question.

For my opinion and answer, I say that Archie Sonic comics or story confuses us with Sega's Sonic's story or plot line. It destroys the fandom and the story of Sonic himself. To me, Yuji Naka is right. He quitted because of Sega messing around with his own made character Sonic.

To me, I think Archie Sonic should just stop the Sonic comics because, to me, it's just messing every single bit of Sonic out.

To me, I think Sega Sonic should just stick with Sonic's real personality, real background and real life from them so that it would have originality. Plus, Sega Sonic shouldn't be mixed with the western style because he is known as a Japanese character made by a Japanese guy. But, I cannot also agree with the former because they also put Sonic to a nice point level.

Sega Sonic and Archie Sonic both have issues because Sega Sonic is too western and very, VERY corny, not much of his real style of impressing his fans while Archie Sonic is the same though it's VERY complicated because it makes Sonic an asshole. He is so not him because the REAL Sonic is very very care-free with his buddy Tails. The REAL Sonic doesn't have a lover too and treats everyone as his friends.

I prefer to stick with the real, Japanese, original, one and only, Sonic the hedgehog. Cocky, cute, talented, care-free, loyal, and a very awesome friend ready to ruin Eggman's evil plans for the fun.

I love him very but both worlds just ruin him so much.