Well I can't really judge this fairly b/c New Moon hasn't come out yet...
But New Moon for sure (judging it strictly on the trailers) since I loved the book, he's shirtless in a lot of it (drool), plus he's much older and more mature now. He was like, what, 12 when he was in CBTD2? I definately prefer the older, hotter Taylor (not to mention the fact that Taylor gets like 10x more screen time in New Moon than he did in CBTD2)!
posted over a year ago
I know the movie hasn't come out yet but you should have seen pictures by now.